How to Conduct a Recruitment Audit (and Solve Bottlenecks)

Recruiters are facing a talent shortage, with 86% of hiring managers reporting difficulties finding qualified candidates. But while many point to skill gaps and changing workforce expectations, another issue is flying under the radar: the recruitment process itself.

Consider just one stat, for instance: 60% of job seekers abandon applications due to length and complexity. Small issues like these combine to create big problems. A recruitment audit can help you catch these issues and start working on solutions. 

In this Willo guide, we'll walk you through practical steps to evaluate your hiring process and connect with top candidates faster.

What Is a Recruitment Audit?

A recruitment audit is a systematic review of your hiring process to uncover inefficiencies, remove obstacles, and ensure it’s streamlined for your organization’s needs. 

A typical recruitment audit includes key components like: 

• Team structure and strategies: Making sure your recruitment team’s organization and approach align with hiring goals.
• Performance metrics: Analyzing key metrics like time-to-hire, interviews to hire ratio, and cost-per-hire to measure recruitment effectiveness.
• Candidate experience: Evaluating the entire candidate journey to identify and resolve any pain points.
• Equity, diversity, and inclusion (ED&I): Checking that recruitment practices support diversity and inclusion.  
• Technology and tools: Confirming that digital tools are enhancing, not hindering, efficiency in the hiring process.

Each of these components provides a clearer picture of your recruitment strengths and areas for improvement, forming the foundation for a more efficient hiring process.

Why Should Companies Conduct a Recruitment Audit? 

Improve efficiency and reduce bottlenecks

Think of your audit as a way to identify and clear up any inefficiencies that slow down hiring and increase expenses. By examining each step, you can: 

• Streamline or automate tasks: Cutting down manual or repetitive steps lets your team focus on building relationships with top candidates.
• Cut unnecessary expenses: Refining recruitment methods, like consolidating interview rounds, saves time and resources.

With these adjustments, you’ll speed up hiring, reduce costs, and free up resources to spend where they make the most impact.

Improve quality of hire

An audit lets you fine-tune each hiring step to attract better and select candidates who truly fit. This can involve:

• Evaluating assessment methods: Find out whether your interviews and screening tools actually gauge the skills and competencies that matter most.
• Clarifying job descriptions: Job descriptions that clearly reflect the role and your company culture help attract the right candidates and reduce mismatches.

When you make these improvements, you end up with hires who are better suited to your team, making a lasting positive impact on your company’s culture and productivity.

Enhance candidates experience

The recruitment process isn’t just about assessing candidates—it’s also about how they perceive you as an employer. An audit can help you:

• Simplify application steps: Cutting down on complex or lengthy applications keeps candidates engaged and prevents drop-offs.
• Improve communication: Regular updates show candidates you respect their time and value their interest in joining your team.

A positive candidate experience isn’t just nice to have—it’s essential for attracting top talent and building a solid reputation.

How to Perform an Effective Recruitment Audit

Step 1: Map out the candidate journey

The first step of your audit is creating a detailed map of your current recruitment process. You need to know exactly what you're auditing before you can evaluate it effectively. To do this well, you need to take a systematic approach:

a. Document each stage

Create a comprehensive outline of your entire recruitment process:

• Sourcing: Job boards, social channels, referral programs
• Application: Application forms, resume screening tools, initial filters
• Screening: Phone screens, assessment tools, video interviews
• Interviewing: Interview rounds, panels, technical assessments
• Selection: Decision-making process, offer creation, negotiations
• Onboarding: Paperwork, system access, training schedules

For each stage, document:

• Tools and systems used
• Team members involved
• Standard processes and procedures
• Time typically spent
• Key decision points
• Communication touchpoints

This detailed mapping gives you a clear picture of what you're actually auditing and where to look for improvements.

b. Add data to your map

Enrich your process documentation with real numbers to understand current performance:

• Volume metrics: Number of candidates at each stage
• Conversion rates: Percentage moving between stages
• Time data: Days spent in each phase
• Drop-off points: Where candidates exit the process
• Bottlenecks: Stages with consistent delays
• Resource allocation: Team hours spent per stage

Pro tip: If you don’t have any of these metrics or pieces of information, it’s time to get it—you can’t improve without benchmarks and you can’t identify success without measurement.

Complement these metrics with qualitative feedback from candidates and your recruitment team. 

Use tools like SurveyMonkey or Typeform to gather structured feedback about their experience at each stage. This combination of hard data and real experiences will give you a complete picture of your recruitment process's strengths and pain points.

Step 2: Map out internal processes

After understanding how candidates experience your hiring process, turn your attention inward. How does your team actually get hiring done? This behind-the-scenes view often reveals unexpected bottlenecks and inefficiencies.

a. Document team workflows

Start by mapping how work moves through your recruitment team:

• Who owns different stages of the process
• How applications get reviewed and sorted
• Where hiring decisions get made (and potentially stuck)
• How teams collaborate and share information
• What tools and systems support each activity
• Where manual work is slowing things down

For each workflow, note common workarounds or pain points. Teams often develop unofficial processes to get things done—understanding these can highlight where your formal process can be updated. This may not make a difference for existing employees, but it’s important when onboarding new recruiters.

b. Track decision-making flows

Document how hiring decisions actually happen:

• Initial application review criteria
• Interview advancement decisions
• Assessment evaluation standards
• Offer approval requirements
• Communication protocols with candidates

Pay special attention to where decisions tend to stall. Is it waiting for hiring manager feedback? Multiple approval layers? 

For example, many companies find their traditional phone screening process creates major bottlenecks—if you spend 30-45 minutes screening each candidate, screening just 20 applicants eats up two full workdays.

Switching to asynchronous video interviews through platforms like Willo can dramatically reduce this bottleneck while giving candidates the flexibility to interview on their own time. Plus, you speed up the decision-making process thanks to easy sharing tools, notes, comments, Scorecards, and more.

c. Gather team insights

Your recruitment team deals with these processes daily—they'll spot issues you might miss. 

Create opportunities for honest feedback through individual conversations, team workshops, and anonymous surveys. Regular check-ins about what's working (and what isn't) help build a complete picture of your process challenges.

Tools like Willo can help by letting recruiters record feedback asynchronously, making it easier to collect detailed insights without disrupting their daily work. Plus, we offer AI-generated summaries that can help you mine responses for key details.

Step 3: Review recruitment sources and channels

To get the best talent for your team, it’s important to know where your strongest candidates are coming from and where resources might be better spent.

a. List all active channels

Start by identifying each platform your team uses to find candidates—whether it’s job boards like LinkedIn and Indeed, social media, employee referrals, or external agencies. Seeing everything in one place makes it easier to compare their effectiveness.

b. Track performance metrics

Examine key metrics to see which channels perform best:

• Candidate volume: Which sources bring in the most applicants?
• Quality of hires: Where are your highest-performing, long-term hires coming from?
• Time-to-fill: How quickly do candidates from each source move through the process?

c. Compare costs and market positioning

Consider both the direct costs (like job posting fees) and indirect costs (like the time your team spends managing each source). This helps you see where your recruitment budget is really paying off.

As part of this analysis, it's valuable to understand how your channels and messaging compare to others in your industry:

• Review job listings on your primary channels to benchmark your role descriptions, requirements, and offered benefits
• Analyze which channels are most active in your industry and whether you're present on all relevant platforms
• Note innovative approaches others are using to attract candidates (like video job descriptions or social media campaigns) that might enhance your own channel strategy

This market research helps ensure your recruitment channels are not just cost-effective but also competitive and aligned with industry best practices.

Step 4: Uncover patterns and implement changes

The final step in your recruitment audit is to pull together all the data and feedback you’ve gathered, uncover key patterns, and make meaningful changes. This is where insights turn into action.

Start by identifying any recurring themes in the data—look for:

• Common bottlenecks: Are there specific steps that slow things down repeatedly?
• Candidate experience trends: Are there points where candidates often feel frustrated or tend to drop off?
• High-performing channels: Which recruitment sources consistently bring in quality hires?

With these patterns in mind, develop an action plan to address each area:

• Streamline steps that feel repetitive or overly complicated.
• Refine communication with candidates at key touchpoints to improve engagement.
• Focus your resources on the channels that yield the best results.

After implementing these changes, keep tracking your process to make sure the adjustments are working. Regularly reviewing and fine-tuning will help you build an efficient, candidate-friendly recruitment process that adapts as your needs evolve.

For example, Florence found candidate screening and identity verification to be bottlenecks to scaling its recruiting operations internationally. Willo helped the company to scale to multiple countries, with Florence now screening and verifying as many as 1,400 candidates per month.  

Use Willo to Streamline Your Recruitment Process

A recruitment audit gives you the insights needed to streamline hiring and attract top talent, and Willo can make this process easier and more effective. With tools like  assessment interviews, AI-generated summaries, and more, our platform helps you gather meaningful data and feedback every step of the way. 

Ready to transform the way you hire? Experience the power of Willo and connect with top talent faster than ever—try it today!

‍